Making Up the Recitation of Shema During the Evening Prayer - Ish Tsadik
Question:
Does a person who failed to recite the Recitation of Shema (Kriat Shema) during the day have a makeup obligation (Tashlumin) at night?
Answer

This is a major dispute; see the words of the Raviah (Megillah siman 571), Sefer HaBatim (Kriat Shema, Sha’ar 2, siman 7), the Pri Chadash (58, se’if katan 7), the Makor Chaim (ibid., se’if katan 7), and the Magen Giborim (ibid., se’if katan 14). Since the Shulchan Aruch (ibid., se’if 7) brings down a dispute regarding this matter, therefore, if one forgot or was prevented by unavoidable circumstances (oness), one may recite Kriat Shema after the prayer. However, his reward is certainly only like one who reads from the Torah [rather than fulfilling the specific mitzvah of Shema in its proper time], as the Gra (Rabbi Eliyahu, the Vilna Gaon) wrote (ibid., se’if katan 17) according to the opinion of those who forbid it.

29.05.2026
Helping those in need

Donate now to the organization's activities and assist needy families who require help.

Baby food and diapers from needy families
Assistance to patients
Financial assistance for families the needy and the elderly