Kaddish in an Aveilim Minyan - Ish Tsadik
Question:
We were in a Minyan today consisting of ten mourners (Avelim), with no additional person present to answer the Kaddish. How should we have acted?
Answer

This question is discussed in the book Rav Pe’alim (Part 2, Siman 14). He concludes the ruling that it is permitted, because the instruction “and [they shall] say Amen” refers to the ministering angels.

Certainly, it is preferable that there be two people to answer, or at the very least one (see Minchas Yitzchak Part 4, Siman 30). However, in this case, where there was no one else to answer, it is permitted to recite the Kaddish

13.02.2026
Helping those in need

Donate now to the organization's activities and assist needy families who require help.

Baby food and diapers from needy families
Assistance to patients
Financial assistance for families the needy and the elderly