Three Men Reciting Zimun Over a Cup of Wine - Ish Tsadik
Question:
If three people ate together, must they recite Zimun over a cup of wine?
Answer

Ideally (L’chatchila), there is a Mitzvah to perform Zimun over a cup of wine, as it is written: “I will lift the cup of salvation and call upon the name of the Lord” (Siman 182, Se’if 7 and Mishna Berurah ibid.). However, when there is no wine available in the house, we are lenient and may perform the Zimun without a cup.

There is a dispute among the authorities as to whether Birchas HaMazon requires a cup even when eating alone (Yachid); however, the common custom is not to use a cup when eating alone (Siman 182 and Mishna Berurah ibid.). Even when three people eat together, the general practice is to be lenient and recite the blessings without a cup (ibid. and Kaf HaChaim).

On the other hand, I found in Ohr L’Tzion (Part 46) that it is proper to be stringent when three people eat together and recite the blessings over a cup.

01.02.2026
Helping those in need

Donate now to the organization's activities and assist needy families who require help.

Baby food and diapers from needy families
Assistance to patients
Financial assistance for families the needy and the elderly